Example Of A Successful Mediation – HOA vs Land Owner

At our agency, we often encounter cases that require mediation to navigate through disputes and find mutually agreeable solutions. In this blog post, we’ll share a recent mediation case that highlights the effectiveness of this conflict resolution approach. It involved a property owner and a Homeowners Association (HOA) in a somewhat informal subdivision, emphasizing the importance of mediation in resolving complex issues.

The Setting: A Unique Subdivision Dispute: The dispute revolved around a property owner in a subdivision where homes were individually built over the years, resulting in a diverse neighborhood. Most houses were constructed in the 1970s and 1980s, and a few vacant lots remained. The property owner in question sought to build a non-traditional 900-square-foot house, akin to a tiny house, with an attached RV pad for recreational use. The conflict arose when the HOA objected, citing design standards that, in their view, the proposed structure did not meet.

The Mediation Process: As mediation advocates, we respect the privacy of our clients and don’t disclose personal details. However, sharing the dynamics of the case can provide insights for potential clients facing similar situations. Both parties willingly participated in the mediation process, avoiding identification while still shedding light on essential details.

Key Points of Contention: The property owner’s vision clashed with the HOA’s design standards. The latter was concerned about the property being perceived as an RV park, fearing a departure from the neighborhood’s residential character. The property owner, on the other hand, had carefully planned a high-end, 900-square-foot house with an RV pad for personal use.

Mediation Unveils Opportunities: During mediation, we carefully listened to both parties’ perspectives. The property owners emphasized their desire for a quality, unique residence, showcasing detailed floor plans and elevations. Simultaneously, the HOA expressed concerns about maintaining the residential nature of the subdivision.

Discovering Common Ground: Mediation is a process of finding common ground, and in this case, it involved a significant shift in perspective. The property owner agreed to modify their original plans, flipping the layout to ensure the residential structure became the primary visual element. To address the HOA’s concern about square footage, a small utility room was added to the overhang, bringing the total square footage closer to 1,000 square feet.

Win-Win Solutions: The modified plans satisfied both parties, preserving the neighborhood’s integrity while allowing the property owner to build their dream home. The HOA updated its regulations to acknowledge past smaller residences as grandfathered, solidifying the community’s standards.

Avoiding Litigation: Mediation not only brought about a successful resolution but also helped the parties avoid a lengthy and costly court battle. By fostering open communication and compromise, both sides achieved their objectives without setting potentially unfavorable legal precedents.

This case exemplifies the power of mediation in navigating complex property disputes. While legal advice remains crucial, opting for mediation can often lead to creative solutions that preserve the interests of all parties involved. If you find yourself in a potential conflict, consider seeking mediation to explore collaborative avenues for resolution. Feel free to reach out to us through our website for any inquiries or share your thoughts in the comments below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top